You face a tough dilemma if you're in line for a pension at retirement. It could
cost you and your spouse thousands of dollars and take a big chunk out of your children's
inheritance.
It's called the "pension dilemma," because you may end up making a trade-off on
your pension - deciding whether to take your full pension benefit and expose your
spouse to a loss of benefits at your death, or taking less than your maximum benefit
in exchange for continuing benefits after you die for your spouse. Fortunately,
for many couples, there is another alternative. It's known as Pension Maximization.
But first, the pension dilemma: As an example, let's say you'll be eligible for
a $1,000 monthly pension benefit at retirement. That's the value of your benefit
and the amount you will receive under the "single life option." The only problem
is that your benefits will be paid only as long as you live. At your death, your
pension benefits die with you. That's fine if you're single, but not if you're married.
Should you die first, your spouse not only loses you, but also $12,000 a year in
income.
That's why, if you're like most married people, you will select a "joint and survivor
option," which pays benefits as long as either of you is alive. Since your spouse
has a legal claim to your benefits, this is the option automatically offered by
law to married retirees. Before you can elect another option, you must both agree
in writing.
However, the cost can be high. Though the actual number depends on a number of factors,
a typical $1,000 monthly benefit could be reduced significantly. For the sake of
discussion, if a "joint and full survivor option" is selected, that "single life
option" benefit of $1,000 could be reduced by as much as $250. That adds up to $3,000
a year - $30,000 over a ten-year period - in lost benefits.
Pension Maximization Option
Then there is that third option - Pension Maximization. The concept is fairly simple.
Purchase a sufficient amount of permanent life insurance on yourself prior to retirement,
naming your spouse as beneficiary. The death benefit is informally earmarked to
replace the lost pension benefit if you die first.
At retirement, you and your spouse opt to take the single-life benefit option -
receiving your maximum pension benefit for as long as you live.
Use a portion of the additional pension funds - the difference between the amount
for a single versus a joint and survivor benefit - to pay the life insurance premiums.
In order to get an idea if this alternative would work for you, you should first
check with your pension plan administrator and find out about your projected benefits
under the straight life option. Then ask what the decreased amount will be each
month to add your spouse under a survivorship option. Then ask your Wilson Financial
agent, at no cost or obligation to you, to show you a personalized life insurance
illustration. The amount of premium required to keep the policy inforce should be
no larger than the difference between the amount for a single versus a joint and
survivor benefit.
Additionally, if the illustration shows out-of-pocket premium payments ceasing because
dividends are being used to fund the policy, keep in mind that the premium is due
throughout the life of the policy, until the insured dies. Therefore, if the dividend
scale, which is not guaranteed, is reduced, additional out-of-pocket premiums will
be necessary in order for your spouse to obtain the proceeds on your death.
An extremely critical issue to determine is whether or not your pension plan requires
you to select the joint and survivor option in order to continue post-retirement
medical benefits. You may not wish to pursue the Pension Maximization alternative
if it means your medical coverage will cease.
Life insurance rates are based primarily on age. So, the younger you are when you
make this decision, the lower your rates will be. But Pension Maximization may also
work even if you are at or near retirement. The idea is to use a portion of your
full pension benefit to pay the insurance premium. The result can be a win-win situation
for you, your spouse, and your heirs. Here's why:
You receive the maximum pension benefits to which you are entitled.
Your spouse shares in your benefits. Should you die first, even though your pension
stops, your spouse's income continues in the form of insurance proceeds. In fact,
if you like, these insurance proceeds can be set up as an annuity - with income
benefits guaranteed for life.
Should your spouse die first, your benefits will continue. The life insurance can
be cashed in or the beneficiary changed.
Cash values accumulate in your life insurance policy. If you and your partner live
well into your golden years, the insurance can protect other assets for your heirs.
In fact, no matter what happens, your estate can be protected, enabling you to pass
assets on to your children, grandchildren, or a favorite charity.
Is Pension Maximization right for you?
That would depend on you and your spouse's particular situation and pension income
benefit choices available to you by your employer. There are many factors that need
to be taken into consideration, including both your ages, health status, actual
pension benefit, and costs. Still, you owe it to yourself and your spouse to find
out more.
Recommendation : Check with your pension plan administrator and find out
about your projected benefits under the straight life option. Then ask what the
decreased amount will be each month to add your spouse under a survivorship option.
Compare Your Benefit Options
Single Life Option
Benefits continue for as long as the benefit recipient lives, whether the recipient
lives to age 66 or 106. This option pays the maximum monthly benefit amount.
Joint and Full Survivor Option
The same amount of benefit is paid for as long as either recipient is alive. However,
that benefit amount will usually be lower than under the single life option. (Example:
A single life benefit of $1,000 a month may be reduced to $750 a month under the
joint and full survivor option.)
Joint and Reduced Survivor Option
Initial benefits are higher than under the joint and full survivor option, but then
continue after the death of one person at a reduced level, generally 50 percent.
(Example: Joint benefit may be $850, continued at $425 a month to the survivor.)